If you're just starting out on Poshmark, you probably already have a handful of followers. Likely, you got them with zero effort. This is because of automatic or bot-generated follows and engagement, like the kind you'd see on other social media platforms like Twitter or Facebook.

However as soon as you become a seller and want to be serious about getting more sales on Poshmark, these followers can affect your ability to know how large your most valuable audience is.

Today we're going to break down what most valuable audience size means, why this number is so important for you and your Poshmark business, and how to grow this number.

Most valuable audience is one of your best tools to drive more sales

For a Poshmark seller, your most valuable audience is the intersection between your followers and your potential buyers. It looks a little like this:

Diagram of most valuable audience
Most valuable audience = intersection of your followers and your potential buyers

This means that someone can only be in your most valuable audience if they are both your follower AND a potential buyer of your items.

If left alone, most valuable audience seems pretty obvious and a bit useless. However, there's a great insight that can be uncovered by pairing most valuable audience with knowledge we already know about.

Pairing most valuable audience with self-shares

Earlier, we shared how to share fast on Poshmark as well as why you should share. Today we're going to pair sharing with most valuable audience to give you a sense for why most valuable audience size is a number you should care about while selling on Poshmark.

Here's the quick tip: more overlap between your potential buyers and your followers means more consistent sales when sharing.

This makes a lot more sense if you walk through a few scenarios.

Let's imagine you were selling a bralette and your potential buyers are women ages 20-42. However, through some stroke of bad luck, your followers are all men ages 20-42. In this scenario if you self-share to followers, you are almost certainly never going to make a sale because not a single one of your followers are a potential buyer. Your most valuable audience is zero in this scenario, because there is zero overlap.

Zero overlap = zero sales

The scenario above isn't great. Of course, you can always share to a party. If we self-share to the Trendsetting Vibes Posh Party, we might be able to find some women who'd be interested in purchasing a bralette despite the fact that our followers are all men ages 20-42.

No overlap, but still some sales

So this is great. We were able to make some sales. The catch is it's not guaranteed that you can repeat this over and over again, because you were counting on piggybacking on the buyers paying attention to a Posh Party. Since buyers don't participate in every Posh Party they'd be interested in and they also aren't aware of every Posh Party, this isn't something we can consistently count on.

Is there a way we can be a bit more consistent?

Let's tweak our scenario slightly. This time, our followers are women ages 18-30. Notice that for the first time, our followers and potential buyers are overlapping.

Changed followers to women ages 18-30

When followers and potential buyers overlap, this means that self-shares to followers get shown to the overlap. Since this is a highly repeatable action (just self-share again, and all of your followers will see), you have a highly repeatable process for increasing the odds that a potential buyer sees your listing.

Here are some rules based on what we learned above:

  • No overlap between your followers and your potential buyers means self-share to followers has near-zero effect on driving sales.
  • Less overlap between your followers and your potential buyers means self-share to followers is less effective at driving sales.
  • More overlap between your followers and your potential buyers means self-share to followers is more effective at driving sales.
  • Complete overlap between your followers and your potential buyers means self-share to followers has the largest possible positive effect it can have on driving sales.

Isn't that incredible? That's why we call it your most valuable audience.

Sell more on Poshmark, in half the time.

Reading to level up your business? Automatically share up to 4,000 times a day and send offers with the #1 Poshmark bot and sales tool.


No risk, cancel anytime.

Caveat: you can only guess how large your most valuable audience is

Most valuable audience probably sounds pretty useful so far, right? Unfortunately, you can't know exactly how big your most valuable audience. Let me explain...

You know for sure how many followers you have and you can know this number for any person on Poshmark. All you have to do is go to their profile page and look at the number right above Followers. This number is highly accurate and can be trusted.

However, it's impossible to tell how many potential buyers you'll have for your items. Poshmark just doesn't show this number to you and they don't make it easy to find out either. This also makes it impossible to figure out just how many people are in your most valuable audience.

So what do we do now?

The best strategy: smart and aggressive follower growth

The answer becomes a little clearer when we think about what happens at the  extremes. Let's say all users on Poshmark followed you. What would the scenario above look like?

Changed followers to all Poshmark users

According to the drawing above, you'd be able to show your listing to all potential buyers on Poshmark. This is because all of your potential buyers have to have a Poshmark account, so if all Poshmark users are following you then these buyers must be your followers.

If we wind back the clock and ask ourselves how we'd even end up in the scenario where all of Poshmark would follow us, we'd end up realizing that the only difference between this best case scenario and where we are now is number of followers.

This only difference is the number of followers

As shown above, as the number of followers grows, the size of the most valuable audience is guaranteed to either grow or stay the same. This means that our sales should be able to consistently grow as well when paired with self-shares, as we learned earlier.

However, we can probably be smart about this. Poshmark reports that it has over 60 million users, so it's unlikely that we'll be able to follow all Poshmark users in any reasonable amount of time.

Poshmark 2020 data report showing off 60 million users

We can try using some very simple tricks. Even separating by gender (of course, according to what types of items you're looking to sell) while looking for users to follow on Poshmark can save you a lot of time.

If you're creative enough, you can even use a Poshmark bot or Poshmark automation tool like SuperPosher to help save you time and effort by following users that follow top sellers, betting on the fact that people tend to follow users with Poshmark closets filled with items they are interested in and that your Poshmark closet is similar.

Sell more on Poshmark, in half the time.

Reading to level up your business? Automatically share up to 4,000 times a day and send offers with the #1 Poshmark bot and sales tool.


No risk, cancel anytime.